Feedback Discussion • Portfolio Usability and Workflows

As you use the Portfolio EAP, please use this space to share your feedback/comments around the usability of the features and workflows.

Find more posts tagged with

Accepted answers

All comments

jsowalsk

Hi @Dalma_Schnell,

Would you be able to provide a testing environment that has demo courses, evidence, achievements, and skills that we can test with for the tool? Since this instance refreshes each week we want to see what your team is expecting us to do and see which can help if you provide examples.
Is there a test plan we can go by? At first, we cannot tell the difference between Evidence and Showcase portfolios since they look similar.
We do not have the ability to add skills and tags. What exactly do the tags do? What is their purpose?
Students can create their own portfolio but they are not able to delete it, if they wanted to. Is this intended?
For the evaluation portfolio, what is the intended group? Can a portfolio evaluation be created from across a number of courses? Or just associated with a single course?
What are the current visibility and sharing options? Can these be customized, such as shared publicly? Such as sharing this information after graduation.
In the future, will there be personalization options such in addition to the cover image such as a profile picture much like LinkedIn has?

Jessica

jsowalsk

@Dalma_Schnell Other thoughts that I had were -- adding these items:

Having the ability to link out to social media platforms and embed them in the portfolio.

Being able to provide options for visibility, along with a sharing link.

The ability to preview the portfolio you created.

The ability to add credentials that you have earned from credentials.

jsowalsk

@Dalma_Schnell

Thank you for the information.

Regarding tags, it seems as if you can create tags when you create evidence but initially when you see the portfolio you cannot create but you can create achievements and the same thing for skills. What are the use of the tags and who can see them after their created?

Screenshot 2025-06-04 at 4.36.35 PM.png

Screenshot 2025-06-04 at 4.36.53 PM.png

It is great to hear that deleting portfolios, sharing options, and personalization are in the works, but when will this be available for testing. Or is it on the horizon after this is rolled out to production? I feel this is an aggressive timeline and if stuff like this are not added then the portfolio is just bare bones and we are looking for the same basic functionality as we currently have with Portfolium.

jsowalsk

@Dalma_Schnell I am not able to create ideas: https://community.canvaslms.com/t5/Canvas-Portfolio/idb-p/canvas_portfolioidea-board

JamesSekcienski

I agree with the ideas shared by @jsowalsk

The one that stands out the most to be is the need to allow users to edit their own Showcase Portfolio after it is published. I was shocked when I started testing that portfolio type and was going to publish what I had done so far and got the warning that I wouldn't be able to edit it again once it was published. This seems problematic as someone may discover typos or things they need to fix with their content after publishing it, especially if it is only shareable after publishing and they receive feedback. This also creates unnecessary work to duplicate and/or fully create a portfolio just to add new content to the portfolio. If a student starts building their portfolio in their first year, they should be able to continue to edit and add to their Showcase Portfolio as they go through college, gain more experience, gain more achievements, and/or have new work they want to share.

As for the tags, based on your described purpose, it would be helpful if tags there was a way to pre-define common tags. If tags were used for reporting and/or searching in the future, it would be more helpful if there was some encouraged standardization to the tags by offering suggestions rather than users freely entering any value without more details and/or suggestions. While it is ok for students to enter their own if there isn't a matching suggestion, it would be good to try to get them to use values similar to other users for tags.

JamesSekcienski

Regarding the use case of evaluation portfolios you shared the following above:

Evaluation Portfolios: These can be created from a single course or span multiple courses, depending on what makes sense for your program. This is designed to support everything from course-level assessments to long-term, program-level evaluation. The intended group using these typically includes program leads or faculty overseeing initiatives that use portfolios to evaluate learner progress over time.

For programs that wait until the end capstone course, it seems potentially possible for the current workflow to support building an evaluation portfolio that incorporates work from across multiple courses. However, due to the inability to add courses and users once it is published, this doesn't work for programs that have students start building their portfolio at the beginning of their program and add to it throughout the program. For this use case, there would need to be a way for the evaluation portfolio to follow the student and be able to continue to grow with new future requirements added later in other courses. Late-added students and/or transfer students also need the ability to get added to an evaluation portfolio that has already been published.

Nonetheless, even programs that wait until the end capstone course would face challenges with adding Canvas assignment requirements from throughout the program history. Students may have variability in the courses they take based on electives and/or transfer status. Program leads and/or faculty of the capstone course also are unlikely to be an instructor in all of the course sections that they may want to sample work from (not to mention the multiple sections of courses in a program), so they wouldn't have access to those courses to select work and would need to use more generic requirements instead. This could also become very tedious to select content from all the past possible courses/sections with the current process even if they did have access. It would be nice if students could select their own work from a previous course to submit as evidence for a generic project requirement. This would eliminate the need for the program lead or faculty to try to account for the different possible past courses while still allowing the student to identify their own past work that potentially meets the requirements. The instructor may consider including in the description examples of past course work that may meet the requirement while keeping it open also for students to submit new original evidence or an improved version of prior course work, if needed.

JamesSekcienski

There needs to be a better handling of users that have mixed Canvas roles (i.e. admins, teachers, and/or students). Users that are teachers/admins also need access as a student in case they are taking classes as a student where they need to submit an evaluation portfolio.

One possible idea I would suggest is to have different views that users can switch between when they have mixed roles that need to be handled different. Thus, if someone is both a teacher and a student, perhaps it defaults them to the teacher perspective and only shows courses where they are a teacher so they can set-up evaluation portfolios for those classes. Then, they would have an option to switch to their student view so they can see any assigned evaluation portfolios.

If they aren't completely separate views, I would recommend at least separating the portfolios into groups. Perhaps one for personal showcase portfolios. One for evaluation portfolios they have been assigned to complete as a student. Then one for evaluation portfolios they have created and/or have access to evaluate.

When creating an evaluation portfolio, it also doesn't make sense for someone to be able to create an evaluation portfolio nor assess an evaluation portfolio that they will be assigned as a student. At a minimum though, I would expect a warning message with a confirmation if you attempt to create an evaluation portfolio for a course where you are enrolled as a student.

PennyBarter

Hi Dalma and team! Thank you for the opportunity to test the new portfolio tool - we're really excited about the possibilities! Here are some thoughts/feedback from my testing so far.

Big things

As others have mentioned (including @JamesSekcienski in this thread!), the ability to edit both the Showcase and Evaluation portfolios is really important to us. In the case of VU Amsterdam, our new Canvas courses are created one semester at a time, which means evaluation portfolios could only be created close to the end of the year/program. Since that's been raised in other places, I'll leave it there.
In the instructions for creating a portfolio in the Canvas Community, it says "Add an admin user if you want to explore portfolio setup or tracking from an institutional perspective." Does this mean that only users with an admin role will be able to create evaluation portfolios when the tool is live, or is this just for testing purposes?

Small things (nice to have in the future)

Creating sections for evidence went very smoothly, but I initially struggled with figuring out how to assign evidence requirements to specific sections (ie. knowing to open Manage Sections and go from there). It would be great if evidence requirements could be dragged and dropped between sections on the main portfolio page (like dragging items between modules in Canvas) and/or if it was possible to assign an evidence requirement to an existing section while creating that evidence requirement, perhaps via a dropdown menu (see image 1). I'm not sure if the latter would also work for evidence added from a course though...
There seems to be a problem with the info button when adding alt text to the portfolio cover image - nothing happens when I click it. I love that the user is required to add alt text before saving the image, but some of our users are unfamiliar with best practices for writing alt text, so having some instructions and examples available is definitely important.
This is a tiny thing, but in image 2, the little green check symbol next to the skill "Python" looks like the student has achieved this skill, even though the associated evidence has not yet been added to the portfolio. My guess is that the symbol changes to a filled-in green symbol when the skill is documented, but at a glance it's a little misleading for those evaluating the portfolio. I'm not sure what to suggest instead, as a grey symbol would not be readable on the button.

Thanks again for all your hard work!
Penny

Jeff_F

Hello! @Dalma_Schnell

I was creating a demonstration showcase portfolio and, in the process, discovered that the PowerPoint (.pptx) file type is not allowed. Is this intentional? Can that be changed? I am asking as often times students demonstrate knowledge and skill mastery by creating a presentation. Thanks! ~ Jeff

Jeff_F

Just a note to say thanks to Team Canvas Portfolio. So far about a half dozen students out of thirty-three have submitted a showcase portfolio in a course of mine for this week's assignment submission. Smooth as silk. It's really just so easy now. No issues at all, and it looks snappy as well. Job well done!

Unanswered Questions

Best Use of Portfolios - Difficult to Test so Seeking Input
Hello, Brainstorming how to best use Canvas Portfolios. We have our MBA in Educational Leadership Director who is very interested in using Canvas Portfolio. She has 4 courses that are used. Cohorts start and graduate each year, so students are in these four courses at various times. Students need to include assignments…
Sharing Showcase Portfolio Outside Organization
Started testing the new Portfolio today. Our K-12 district is new to Canvas and never implemented a portfolio solution. I was testing the share as a studnet using the 'Anyone can view link' to an outside user = does not have a login ID for our instance of Canvas. As the outside user, I am able to open and read the…
Recurring error message with Portfolios
I am experimenting with Canvas Portfolios (the Evaluation type), which we have enabled in one subaccount in our production environment, and this morning, I keep getting a red error message, reading that "You are not allowed to perform this action. Please contact your administrator." Except, I'm one of the root account…
Multiple portfolios for students not working
We installed the new Portfolio on our beta server. I created an evaluation portfolio for a course with a test student I added to the course. The portfolio was generated for the student. I created another evaluation portfolio using a different teacher account and attaching a different course but with the same test student…
503 error
When trying to launch the Portfolio tool in Beta, anyone else get a 503 error? Not allowing creation of either portfolio type- spinning when trying to load the list of coures for evaluation portfolio.