So one of my favorite things about being a Canvas user is that we can create and vote on changes we would like to see the company implement into the system. However as I was looking today at the current list available to vote on, I was discouraged by the sheer volume of feature requests. There was over 30 pages of requests! How in the world are people going to ever find things? There is search functionality, but it's still a lot to sift through if you are just looking for other ideas. Well I decided to make a "Top 40 of Buried Feature Ideas" to help out some of the ideas that I think have some merit but are buried under a few other pages of other good ideas. So in order of least votes at the time of making this list, here they are. If you are a Canvas user, log in to the community and go vote on these.
Originally post on my blog A Story to Tell on July 2, 2015
This is great @mjennings ! One thing I really encourage people to think about when it comes to feature ideas, is to really consider what's most important to you and your institution. And with that in mind... don't just go vote up all feature ideas that "sound good." I'd say about 90+% of the feature ideas that have been submitted are GREAT ideas. But its likely that not all of them are a real priority to you and your institution.
So here's my challenge...
Don't be so quick to pull the :smileyplus: vote trigger! And don't be scared to :smileyminus: vote if you think Instructure should not spend their time developing an idea. Rationale for your downvote is commonly appreciated, but not required. Consider this paradigm by @dhulsey regarding voting for feature ideas:
"Instructure... has limited resources and must make decisions about what new features to implement and prioritize. If I down vote, I often don't mind the idea, but I am down voting as a way to lessen the priority of that idea and to boost the ideas I want Instructure to focus on right now. in other words, I can champion the features I want by voting for them and by voting against other, competing features." (see full thread)
As you acknowledge the finite resources that Instructure has and the seemingly infinite number of feature ideas that continue to pour in, please weigh in on and vote for the feature ideas that are of highest priority to you and your institution. Imagine that you were the one that had to sift through over 1,000 ideas, and you could not develop them all. Which ones would you and your institution spend your efforts developing? These are the ideas you should vote up emphatically! (how does one vote emphatically?? 😉 You know... click the ^ vote and then add a constructive comment with an explicit description of why it's important to you... maybe include some use-cases... some suggestions on how you'd like to see the feature functioning... a mockup screenshot, etc.)
You don't need to down-vote the other ideas, necessarily, but just consider not voting up every good idea, just because it's a good idea.
Onward and upward!
Wow! – I had no idea there are so many Canvas Feature Ideas (1,025). Thanks Matthew for showing how involved everyone is in the community to improve Canvas! Made me realize that it can be a little overwhelming and hard to follow at times. I know you can filter by text but maybe it would help to categorize the ideas so you can quickly see what is trending on quizzes or modules, no matter what stage they are in? Might be there already and I am overlooking it?
According to my rough count, there are over 600 feature ideas currently open for voting. @mjennings , I'd love to see an update! Yes, I know I could figure out which ideas haven't garnered many votes, but what I'd really be interested in is which of these ideas you think deserve a closer look.
And I agree with @dhulsey --in consideration of a fair allocation of limited resources, downvotes are important too! Personally, I use downvotes sparingly, and only if I'm prepared to write a comment providing a rationale for my downvote.
Thanks for doing this Matthew, although I didn't see any of my ideas on your list. :smileysilly:
Every time I see a discussion like this, I always go back to one I started not long after Canvas made the transition to the new community: Limits on Feature Requests in Jive?
I still think there's some usefulness for a queue type idea, seeing as how this discussion is still going on 5 months later and I don't see any sign of feature ideas letting up (based on the number of new ones I see in my Jive inbox on a daily basis). Better sorting would be a start, but there's gotta be a way to lessen the inundation.
Hey @mjennings and everyone participating in this blog, snugent has just posted this discussion in the Instructional Designers group: Some Great Feature Ideas that Need Votes